Your privacy, your choice

We use essential cookies to make sure the site can function. We also use optional cookies for advertising, personalisation of content, usage analysis, and social media.

By accepting optional cookies, you consent to the processing of your personal data - including transfers to third parties. Some third parties are outside of the European Economic Area, with varying standards of data protection.

See our privacy policy for more information on the use of your personal data.

for further information and to change your choices.
Skip to main content

Table 4 Results of the meta-analyses performed on a subset of the studies included in the systematic review stratifying separately studies that measured the outcomes in children who were 3 or less years from studies that considered children who were more than 3 years. For each combination of exposure and outcome, and for each sex category (boys and girls combined, only boys, and only girls) a meta-analysis was performed only if suitable information was reported from at least 3 studies. In this table, the pooled estimated of the random effects models (with the 95% confidence interval) from the generic invariance method, the I2 of the heterogeneity test, the p-value of the Egger’s test, and the pooled estimated of the random effects models (with the 95% confidence interval) by weighting per sample size are reported. The complete forest and funnel plots are reported in the supplementary figures

From: Prenatal and childhood exposure to per-/polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) and its associations with childhood overweight and/or obesity: a systematic review with meta-analyses

Conditions assessed

Studies included

Random effects model [95% CI]

Generic invariance method

Heterogeneity (I2)

Egger’s test p-value

Random effects model [95% CI]

Weighted per sample size

Prenatal PFOA and BMI in both sexes

0–3 years

[76, 86, 89, 91]

-0.0140 [-0.0351; 0.0070]

0.77

0.910

-0.0133 [-0.0343; 0.0078]

4–18 years

[64, 69, 70, 74, 75, 79, 81, 83, 87, 88, 90, 92, 94]

0.0000 [-0.0008; 0.0009]

0.24

0.047

0.0275 [0.0059; 0.0491]

Prenatal PFOA and BMI in boys

0–3 years

[68, 76, 86, 91]

-0.0022 [-0.0070; 0.0026]

0.19

0.533

-0.0051 [-0.0182; 0.0079]

4–18 years

[69, 70, 81,82,83, 87, 88, 92]

0.0000 [-0.0009; 0.0008]

0.00

0.039

-0.0115 [-0.0398; 0.0168]

Prenatal PFOA and BMI in girls

0–3 years

[68, 76, 86, 91]

-0.0036 [-0.0413; 0.0341]

0.87

0.673

-0.0087 [-0.0313; 0.0139]

4–18 years

[69, 70, 78, 81,82,83, 87, 88, 92]

0.0000 [-0.0001; 0.0002]

0.23

0.672

0.0115 [-0.0084; 0.0313]

Prenatal PFOS and BMI in both sexes

0–3 years

[76, 86, 89, 91]

-0.0101 [-0.0189; -0.0013]

0.38

0.965

-0.0092 [-0.0210; 0.0026]

4–18 years

[64, 69, 70, 74, 75, 79, 81, 83, 87, 88, 90, 92, 94]

0.0002 [-0.0009; 0.0014]

0.42

0.251

0.0008 [-0.0056; 0.0072]

Prenatal PFOS and BMI in boys

0–3 years

[68, 76, 86, 91]

-0.0024 [-0.0071; 0.0024]

0.21

0.123

-0.0060 [-0.0128; 0.0007]

4–18 years

[69, 70, 81,82,83, 87, 88, 92]

0.0002 [-0.0029; 0.0033]

0.00

0.538

-0.0026 [-0.0128; 0.0077]

Prenatal PFOS and BMI in girls

0–3 years

[68, 76, 86, 91]

-0.0065 [-0.0186; 0.0056]

0.78

0.356

-0.0086 [-0.0198; 0.0026]

4–18 years

[69, 70, 78, 81,82,83, 87, 88, 92]

-0.0006 [-0.0033; 0.0021]

0.56

0.883

0.0065 [-0.0019; 0.0150]

Prenatal PFHxS and BMI in both sexes

4–18 years

[64, 69, 70, 75, 81, 83, 87, 90, 92]

0.0000 [-0.0071; 0.0071]

0.00

0.435

-0.0009 [-0.0600; 0.0582]

Prenatal PFHxS and BMI in boys

0–3 years

[68, 76, 86]

-0.0023 [-0.0054; 0.0009]

0.00

0.659

0.0159 [-0.0998; 0.1317]

4–18 years

[69, 70, 81, 83, 87, 92]

0.0040 [-0.0108; 0.0188]

0.00

0.051

-0.0694 [-0.1534; 0.0146]

Prenatal PFHxS and BMI in girls

0–3 years

[68, 76, 86]

0.0343 [-0.0360; 0.1046]

0.33

0.463

0.0806 [-0.0197; 0.181]

4–18 years

[69, 70, 78, 81, 83, 87, 92]

-0.0014 [-0.0050; 0.0021]

0.00

0.387

0.0221 [-0.0348; 0.0790]

Prenatal PFNA and BMI in both sexes

4–18 years

[64, 69, 70, 75, 81, 83, 87, 90, 92]

-0.0001 [-0.0033; 0.0030]

0.00

0.072

0.0656 [-0.0252; 0.1564]

Prenatal PFNA and BMI in boys

0–3 years

[68, 76, 86]

-0.0083 [-0.0183; 0.0016]

0.00

0.831

0.0009 [-0.0495; 0.0513]

4–18 years

[69, 70, 81, 83, 87, 92]

0.0022 [-0.0052; 0.0097]

0.17

0.120

0.1851 [0.0280; 0.3421]

Prenatal PFNA and BMI in girls

0–3 years

[68, 76, 86]

0.0216 [-0.0031; 0.0463]

0.52

0.119

0.0588 [-0.0023; 0.1198]

4–18 years

[69, 70, 78, 81, 83, 87, 92]

-0.0002 [-0.0027; 0.0023]

0.05

0.290

0.0976 [-0.0355; 0.2307]

Prenatal PFDA and BMI in both sexes

4–18 years

[69, 70, 87, 90]

-0.0007 [-0.003; 0.0015]

0.00

0.001

-0.0816 [-0.2605; 0.0973]

Prenatal PFDA and BMI in boys

0–3 years

[68, 76, 86]

-0.0069 [-0.0286; 0.0147]

0.00

0.196

0.0365 [-0.0673; 0.1402]

4–18 years

[69, 70, 87]

0.0016 [-0.0038; 0.0070]

0.00

0.410

-0.0111 [-0.3852; 0.3630]

Prenatal PFDA and BMI in girls

0–3 years

[68, 76, 86]

0.0111 [-0.0205; 0.0427]

0.41

0.407

0.1055 [-0.0437; 0.2546]

4–18 years

[69, 70, 87]

-0.0017 [-0.0077; 0.0043]

0.00

0.829

-0.1628 [-0.4729; 0.1474]

Prenatal PFUA and BMI in both sexes

4–18 years

[64, 69, 70, 87]

-0.0015 [-0.0048; 0.0017]

0.00

0.749

-0.3931 [-1.2412; 0.4549]

Prenatal PFUA and BMI in boys

4–18 years

[69, 70, 87]

0.0021 [-0.0055; 0.0098]

0.00

0.263

0.2827 [-0.2755; 0.8409]

Prenatal PFUA and BMI in girls

4–18 years

[69, 70, 87]

-0.0045 [-0.0098; 0.0008]

0.00

0.325

-0.0501 [-0.4704; 0.3701]

Prenatal PFOA and risk of overweight

4–18 years

[70, 71, 74, 83, 84, 90, 92, 94]

0.0084 [-0.0003; 0.0171]

0.02

0.063

0.0142 [-0.0006; 0.0289]

Prenatal PFOS and risk of overweight

4–18 years

[70, 71, 74, 83, 84, 90, 92, 94]

0.0007 [-0.0012; 0.0026]

0.19

0.504

0.0016 [-0.0018; 0.0050]

Prenatal PFHxS and risk of overweight

4–18 years

[70, 71, 83, 84, 90, 92]

-0.0035 [-0.0235; 0.0166]

0.41

0.312

-0.0627 [-0.1201; -0.0052]

Prenatal PFNA and risk of overweight

4–18 years

[70, 71, 83, 84, 90, 92]

0.025 [-0.0116; 0.0616]

0.02

0.338

-0.0633 [-0.1611; 0.0344]

Prenatal PFOA and WC in both sexes

4–18 years

[65, 69, 70, 81, 83, 87, 92]

0.0000 [-0.0001; 0.0000]

0.00

0.232

0.0007 [-0.0171; 0.0184]

Prenatal PFOA and WC in boys

4–18 years

[69, 70, 81,82,83, 87, 92]

-0.0001 [-0.0002; 0.0001]

0.00

0.199

-0.0023 [-0.0218; 0.0173]

Prenatal PFOA and WC in girls

4–18 years

[69, 70, 78, 81,82,83, 87, 92]

0.0000 [-0.0001; 0.0001]

0.43

0.939

-0.0040 [-0.0194; 0.0114]

Prenatal PFOS and WC in both sexes

4–18 years

[65, 69, 70, 81, 83, 87, 92]

0.0000 [0.0000; 0.0001]

0.00

0.675

-0.0038 [-0.0115; 0.0039]

Prenatal PFOS and WC in boys

4–18 years

[69, 70, 81,82,83, 87, 92]

0.0000 [-0.0001; 0.0001]

0.00

0.492

-0.0012 [-0.0093; 0.0068]

Prenatal PFOS and WC in girls

4–18 years

[69, 70, 78, 81,82,83, 87, 92]

-0.0001 [-0.0004; 0.0003]

0.51

0.631

0.0015 [-0.0053; 0.0083]

Prenatal PFHxS and WC in both sexes

4–18 years

[65, 69, 70, 81, 83, 87, 92]

0.0003 [-0.0014; 0.0020]

0.13

0.621

-0.0069 [-0.0420; 0.0281]

Prenatal PFHxS and WC in boys

4–18 years

[69, 70, 81, 83, 87, 92]

-0.0001 [-0.0041; 0.0039]

0.19

0.726

-0.0518 [-0.1069; 0.0032]

Prenatal PFHxS and WC in girls

4–18 years

[69, 70, 78, 81, 83, 87, 92]

0.0000 [-0.0004; 0.0005]

0.06

0.675

0.0144 [-0.0285; 0.0572]

Prenatal PFNA and WC in both sexes

4–18 years

[65, 69, 70, 81, 83, 87, 92]

0.0004 [-0.0006; 0.0015]

0.14

0.051

0.0411 [-0.0002; 0.0824]

Prenatal PFNA and WC in boys

4–18 years

[69, 70, 81, 83, 87, 92]

-0.0001 [-0.0006; 0.0003]

0.00

0.070

0.0477 [-0.0105; 0.1059]

Prenatal PFNA and WC in girls

4–18 years

[69, 70, 78, 81, 83, 87, 92]

0.0010 [-0.0002; 0.0023]

0.00

0.779

-0.0035 [-0.0509; 0.0438]

Prenatal PFDA and WC in both sexes

4–18 years

[69, 70, 87]

0.0003 [-0.0002; 0.0008]

0.00

0.956

0.0324 [-0.1791; 0.2438]

Prenatal PFDA and WC in boys

4–18 years

[69, 70, 87]

-0.0001 [-0.0004; 0.0003]

0.00

0.738

0.0312 [-0.3097; 0.3721]

Prenatal PFDA and WC in girls

4–18 years

[69, 70, 87]

0.0010 [-0.0001; 0.0021]

0.00

0.963

0.0329 [-0.2441; 0.3100]

Prenatal PFUA and WC in both sexes

4–18 years

[69, 70, 87]

0.0005 [-0.0010; 0.0020]

0.67

0.345

0.3729 [0.0703; 0.6755]

Prenatal PFUA and WC in boys

4–18 years

[69, 70, 87]

0.0002 [-0.0044; 0.0049]

0.38

0.195

0.5132 [-0.1139; 1.1404]

Prenatal PFUA and WC in girls

4–18 years

[69, 70, 87]

0.0015 [-0.0015; 0.0045]

0.00

0.242

0.2805 [-0.1624; 0.7234]

Childhood PFOA and BMI in both sexes

4–18 years

[64, 79, 81, 90, 98, 104, 105, 111]

-0.0525 [-0.1039; -0.0012]

0.84

0.023

-0.0445 [-0.0604; -0.0286]

Childhood PFOA and BMI in boys

4–18 years

[81, 98, 111]

-0.0910 [-0.2488; 0.0668]

0.89

0.394

-0.0410 [-0.2285; 0.1464]

Childhood PFOA and BMI in girls

4–18 years

[81, 98, 111, 112]

-0.0150 [-0.0401; 0.0100]

0.74

0.256

-0.0134 [-0.0456; 0.0187]

Childhood PFOS and BMI in both sexes

4–18 years

[64, 79, 81, 90, 98, 104, 105, 111]

-0.0166 [-0.0283; -0.0049]

0.82

0.011

-0.0226 [-0.0412; -0.0039]

Childhood PFOS and BMI in boys

4–18 years

[81, 98, 111]

-0.0229 [-0.0338; -0.0120]

0.00

0.359

-0.0235 [-0.0354; -0.0116]

Childhood PFOS and BMI in girls

4–18 years

[81, 98, 111]

-0.0162 [-0.0531; 0.0207]

0.84

0.972

-0.0278 [-0.0719; 0.0164]

Childhood PFHxS and BMI in both sexes

4–18 years

[64, 81, 90, 98, 104, 111]

-0.0247 [-0.0814; 0.0320]

0.35

0.260

-0.0334 [-0.1157; 0.0489]

Childhood PFHxS and BMI in boys

4–18 years

[81, 98, 111]

-0.0547 [-0.2558; 0.1464]

0.18

0.444

-0.0331 [-0.1620; 0.0957]

Childhood PFHxS and BMI in girls

4–18 years

[81, 98, 111]

0.0667 [-0.1136; 0.2469]

0.35

0.079

0.0399 [-0.1249; 0.2047]

Childhood PFNA and BMI in both sexes

4–18 years

[64, 81, 90, 104, 111]

-0.2162 [-0.4883; 0.0558]

0.81

0.383

-0.3279 [-0.6121; -0.0438]

Childhood PFOA and risk of overweight in both sexes

4–18 years

[64, 90, 96, 108]

-0.0101 [-0.0497; 0.0295]

0.84

0.413

-0.0074 [-0.0554; 0.0407]

Childhood PFOS and risk of overweight in both sexes

4–18 years

[90, 96, 108]

0.0016 [-0.0081; 0.0113]

0.78

0.231

-0.0007 [-0.0137; 0.0123]

Back to article page

Environmental Health

ISSN: 1476-069X