Skip to main content

Table 3 The combined effects of 5mdC, total urinary arsenic, and blood lead levels on with developmental delay in preschool children

From: Combined effects of global DNA methylation, blood lead and total urinary arsenic levels on developmental delay in preschool children

Total urinary arsenic(μg/L)

Blood lead(μg/dL)

Children with /without developmental delay

Age-sex-adjusted ORs (95%CI)

Multivariate ORs(95%CI)b

≤ 12.55

≤ 3.00

10/26

1.00§,a,***

1.00§,c,***

>12.55

≤ 3.00

22/18

2.22 (0.75 – 6.55)

1.26 (0.36 – 4.42)

≤ 12.55

>3.00

61/18

8.06 (3.12 – 20.78)***

4.89 (1.69 – 14.21)**

>12.55

>3.00

84/26

7.56 (2.90 – 19.76)***

4.27 (1.48 – 12.27)**

  

Synergy index

0.79 (0.34 – 1.84)

0.79 (0.27 – 2.33)

  

p interaction 

0.2047

0.097

5mdC (%)

Total urinary arsenic(μg/L)

   

>5.03

≤ 12.55

9/23

1.00§,a,***

1.00§,c,***

>5.03

>12.55

15/21

1.29 (0.38 – 4.33)

1.21 (0.30 – 4.91)

≤ 5.03

≤ 12.55

62/21

7.12 (2.73 – 18.55)***

8.18 (2.64 – 25.31)**

≤ 5.03

>12.55

88/23

8.55 (3.07 – 23.81)***

8.09 (2.49 – 26.34)**

  

Synergy index

1.18 (0.49 – 2.84)

0.96 (0.35 – 2.60)

  

p interaction 

0.6872

0.7160

5mdC (%)

Blood lead(μg/dL)

   

>5.03

≤ 3.00

0/25

1.00§,***

1.00§,***

>5.03

>3.00

24/19

≤ 5.03

≤ 3.00

32/19

3.00 (1.35 – 6.67)**

4.00 (1.53 – 10.49)**

≤ 5.03

>3.00

118/25

9.63 (4.77 – 19.47)***

9.51 (4.18 – 21.64)***

  

p interaction 

0.011

0.021

5mdC (%)

Total urinary arsenic(μg/L)

Blood lead(μg/L)

Children with /without developmental delay

Age-sex-adjusted ORs (95% CI)a

Multivariate ORs(95% CI)c

>5.03

≤ 12.55

≤ 3.00

0/16

1.00§,***

1.00§,***

>5.03

>12.55

≤ 3.00

9/16

>5.03

> 12.55

>3.00

15/12

4.26 (1.33 – 13.66)*

3.46 (0.90 – 13.37)+

≤ 5.03

≤ 12.55

≤ 3.00

10/10

3.63 (1.07 – 12.33)*

7.87 (1.78 – 34.83)**

≤ 5.03

>12.55

≤ 3.00

74/20

12.48 (4.94 – 31.57)***

10.78 (3.64 – 31.87)***

≤ 5.03

> 12.55

>3.00

66/14

20.11 (7.18 – 56.35)***

18.82 (5.72 – 61.85)***

  1. Abbreviations: OR Odds ratio, CI Confidence interval. 5mdC (%) = ratio of 5-methyl-2'deoxycytidine
  2. p interaction: p value for multiplicative interactions
  3. aAdjusted for age, sex, and urinary creatinine
  4. bAdjusted for age, sex, birth weight, maternal education level, and number of gestational weeks
  5. cAdjusted for age, sex, birth weight, maternal education level, number of gestational weeks, and urinary creatinine
  6. +0.05 ≤ p < 0.1, *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001
  7. §for trend tests